Butt Plugs

Butt plugs are one of those toys people come to for very different reasons. Some are just curious and want to try something small and simple. Others already know what they like and are browsing for a specific size, weight, or material. There’s no single “correct” choice here, and that’s kind of the point.

In this collection, you’ll find a mix of everyday favorites and more specialized styles. Some are meant to be worn briefly, some feel better over longer sessions, and some are really about weight or presence rather than movement.

Beginner Butt Plugs

Most people start with a basic silicone butt plug. Something small, smooth, and easy to handle. This is where brands like NS Novelties tend to show up, with simple designs that don’t try to do too much.

A lot of customers use a beginner plug at home, on their own, just to get used to the feeling. Ten minutes, maybe a bit longer, then back in the drawer until next time. Nothing complicated.

Training Butt Plugs

Training plugs are popular with people who already enjoy anal play but want to move up slowly. Some come as sets, others just have a longer, more gradual shape. These are often chosen after someone has already owned at least one small plug and wants a bit more without jumping straight to something huge.

It’s common to see people mixing training plugs into foreplay, then switching sizes over a few sessions once everything feels more relaxed.

Huge Butt Plugs

Large and extra-large butt plugs are usually picked by people who know exactly what they’re shopping for. These plugs are about fullness and weight, not experimenting. Brands like XR Brands and some specialty lines focus heavily on size and presence rather than subtlety.

Most customers buying huge plugs already own smaller ones and are adding something more intense to their collection.

Metal Butt Plugs

Metal butt plugs are a favorite for people who like weight. Stainless steel designs from brands like Thorn and Feather are known for being solid, heavy, and very simple. No flex, no texture, just steady pressure.

Some people like using metal plugs during longer sessions, others just enjoy how they feel once they warm up to body temperature. They tend to appeal more to experienced users than first-timers.

Glass Butt Plugs

Glass butt plugs are smooth, firm, and straightforward. Many people choose glass because it feels clean and uncomplicated, and it works well with plenty of lubricant. These plugs don’t have buttons or settings — they’re all about shape and weight.

Glass is often picked by people who want something elegant and easy to care for, rather than something playful or high-tech.

Tail Butt Plugs

Tail butt plugs add a visual element that some people really enjoy. They’re common in roleplay, cosplay, or just playful sessions at home. The plug itself works like any other, while the tail is more about style and mood.

People usually choose tail plugs based on comfort first, and looks second, especially if they plan to wear them longer than a few minutes.

Finding What Works for You

What feels right can change depending on mood, experience, or situation. That’s why a lot of people end up owning more than one butt plug. A small silicone plug for relaxed nights, something heavier for when they want more intensity, maybe a glass or metal option for a different feel.

There’s no need to overthink it. Start with what feels manageable, and let experience guide the rest.

Shop Butt Plugs at Thorn & Feather

Our butt plug collection includes a wide range of styles, from beginner-friendly designs to heavier metal and glass options. Whether you’re trying your first plug or adding something new to what you already enjoy, you can browse comfortably and choose at your own pace.

All orders ship discreetly within Canada.